Lady in the Water Well Worth the Dive
Lady in the Water is a fairy tale for grownups, set in an apartment complex somewhere near
Philadelphia. Starring the talented Paul Giamatti (Sideways, Cinderella Man) and Bryce Dallas Howard (daughter of director, Ron Howard), the story asks us – and its main characters – to suspend disbelief and believe that magical things are anchored in, and will improve, our every day life.
I found the film had an interesting plot with somewhat uneven performances, though Howard’s naïf (that’s a water nymph to you and I) is mesmerizing, as well as prophetic, channeling both a calm and yet vulnerable demeanor. You want to believe in her, and you root for her to succeed in her strange, and yet uplifting quest.
Giamatti is well cast as the bumbling, stuttering building manager of this apartment complex, peopled with the unusual eclectic mix of tenants, who all, eventually, reveal striking talents that will come together to solve the puzzle this movie presents. Giamatti’s character will transform and step forward – as will other characters in the movie – to take on roles that, at first, seem outside of themselves.
An interesting aspect of this film is that its director – M. Night Shyamalan, who has often been compared to Alfred Hitchcock – is in the film. And not as a cameo or bit player, which Hitchcock often did, showing up slyly here and there. In Lady, Shyamalan plays a small, but very pivotal, role. And so I must admit that I found that a bit distracting, and hope he doesn’t continue down this Woody Allenesque path. Not that he wasn’t convincing in the role of Vick, the blocked writer. His performance was, in fact, very good. I just worry because most directors cannot do both things well in the same movie, and Shyamalan is a talented director and risks getting distracted (as well as becoming partial to his own performances!)
Overall, I give this movie three out of four stars. Rated PG-13 for some frightening sequences. There was some plot and performance unevenness, but overall I was captivated by Shyamalan’s story telling and directorial style, as well as Giamatti’s and Howard’s performances. This movie is a thriller of sorts – there are some special effect villains on hand to give it that spooky edge – but I think it is safe viewing for anyone over 11. If grandma is adventurous and likes fairy tales, take her. This one is creative and fun.